Overview of the Swiss Federal Supreme Court’s tax law decisions published between November 9 and 15, 2026:
- Judgment of October 16, 2026 (9C_227/2026): Federal Direct Tax and State and Municipal Taxes for 2011–2014 (Vaud); Back taxes; During a VAT audit, the Federal Tax Administration (FTA) determined that A. SA, a civil engineering firm, had recorded large cash payments to an unknown French company as expenses and reported this to the cantonal tax authority. The cantonal tax authority assessed back taxes against the company and its sole shareholder, who was partially assessed on a discretionary basis. The Federal Supreme Court held that the decision not to suspend proceedings until the conclusion of the FTA’s subsequently initiated criminal investigation was not arbitrary. Furthermore, this constituted a new fact rather than a new legal assessment, since the payments could not be attributed to either an identifiable recipient or a proven service. Nor did a final discretionary assessment preclude the assessment of additional taxes. The commercial justification had not been proven, and the sole shareholder had not substantively contested the monetary consideration. The taxpayers’ appeal was dismissed.
- Judgment of October 20, 2026 (9C_549/2026): Value-Added Tax; net tax rate method; tax periods 2014–2019: The Federal Supreme Court had to determine whether the Federal Tax Administration (FTA) was correct in applying the (higher) “wine production” net tax rate instead of confirming the (lower) net tax rate for “wine trade.” The taxpayer, A. AG, had applied the latter rate during the tax periods 2014–2019. During a VAT audit in November 2019, the FTA determined that the taxpayer had wines produced from purchased grapes. The taxpayer purchased grapes from winegrowers and had them pressed and bottled at a winery. It sold the wines under its own name with its own label. The Federal Administrative Court (FAC) upheld the FTA’s position and granted the appeal only in part, to the extent that the tax periods 2014 and 2015 were already time-barred. The Federal Supreme Court (FSC) upheld this ruling. The actual nature of the service is decisive for assigning a net tax rate. “Trade” refers merely to buying and selling, whereas “viticulture” also encompasses the production of wine. The taxpayer selected the producers, purchased the grapes, and organized the production. In doing so, she influenced the value chain at an early stage and did not limit herself to the sale of a finished product. The commercial tax rate would therefore be inappropriate, as it assumes significantly higher input tax-burdened expenses. The taxpayer’s appeal was dismissed.
- Judgment of October 13, 2026 (9C_219/2026): Value-Added Tax 2018–2021; The issue in dispute was whether payments made to two Brazilian companies for the referral of customers should be classified as profit shares from a general partnership—the petitioner as a sole proprietor together with the two aforementioned companies—or as consideration for taxable services rendered to the petitioner, and thus subject to withholding tax; The Federal Supreme Court confirmed that the companies had provided the appellant with taxable services in the form of customer referrals. The “profit-sharing agreements” submitted by the taxpayer did not establish a general partnership, as there was no common purpose involving shared risk; rather, mutual services in exchange for compensation had been agreed upon. This was further supported by the fact that the payments to the Brazilian companies were recorded as expenses in the taxpayer’s accounting records. The taxpayer’s appeal was dismissed.
- Judgment of October 16, 2026 (9C_72/2026): State and Municipal Taxes 2022 (Geneva); The issue in dispute was whether the tax burden imposed on a property owner in Geneva who resided in Israel was confiscatory. The appellant had voluntarily opted for the simplified taxation procedure; consequently, she was not required to disclose either her worldwide assets or her worldwide income, but was taxed at the maximum tax rate in return. The Federal Supreme Court held that a person’s worldwide income and assets are decisive for determining whether taxation is confiscatory. Since the appellant voluntarily waived the disclosure of her worldwide income and assets and opted for the simplified taxation procedure, she could not claim that the tax burden was confiscatory. The taxpayer’s appeal was dismissed.
- Judgment of October 22, 2026 (9C_253/2026): Federal Direct Tax and State and Municipal Taxes for 2020 (Fribourg); the dispute concerned the classification of two loans granted to a company. The appellants had granted two loans to the company and contended that they had done so within the framework of a fiduciary relationship with the D family—residing in Kosovo. Accordingly, they argued that the loan balances should not be taxed as assets and the loan interest should not be taxed as income. The Federal Supreme Court held that the alleged fiduciary relationship had not been sufficiently proven, particularly since the loans had been declared as the taxpayers’ own assets since 2015 and the submitted contracts and proof of payment did not constitute clear evidence of a fiduciary relationship. The taxpayers’ appeal was dismissed.
- Judgment of October 16, 2026 (9C_612/2026): Federal Direct Tax and State and Municipal Taxes for 2016 and 2017 (Schwyz). The taxpayer alleges that the Administrative Court’s orders regarding the advance payment of costs and the threat of dismissal were not properly served on her. The taxpayer’s allegations are manifestly unfounded. The taxpayer’s appeal is dismissed.
- Judgment of October 16, 2026 (9C_618/2026): Federal Direct Tax and State and Municipal Taxes for 2019 (Schwyz). The taxpayer alleges that the Administrative Court’s order granting an extension for payment of the advance on costs and threatening to dismiss the case was not properly served on her. The taxpayer’s allegations are manifestly unfounded. The taxpayer’s appeal is dismissed.
- Judgment of October 22, 2026 (9C_308/2026): Cantonal and municipal taxes and direct federal tax for 2012 (Ticino); Statute of limitations on assessment; acknowledgment of debt; The issue in dispute was whether the right to assess taxes for 2012 had already become relatively time-barred when the assessment was issued in April 2021. In the 2017 tax return filed in April 2019, the taxpayer had unconditionally declared an amount of CHF 701,378 under “Tax Liabilities for Various Years,” which, according to the binding determination of the lower court, also included the estimated tax liability for 2012 arising from commercial real estate transactions. The Federal Supreme Court characterized this as an explicit acknowledgment of the tax claim within the meaning of Art. 120(3)(b) of the Federal Tax Act (DBG), which interrupted the statute of limitations. The fact that the 2012 tax period was not specifically mentioned was not decisive, since the taxpayer had claimed a precise amount without reservation and for the purpose of obtaining a tax benefit. Dismissal of the taxpayer’s appeal.
Non-occurrence / write-off:
Decisions are listed chronologically by publication date.




